top 5 QB in the AFC (this season)
"ST21" lanchbury said 12/17, 11:52 PM
1.brady (duh)
2.romo
3.manning
4.big ben
5.david garrad
soxfan10000 said 12/17, 11:56 PM
1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Derek Anderson - Has become one heck of a quarterback this season, getting the opportunity to shine with those great weapons to throw to like Edwards and Winslow
4. David Garrard - for getting a very good Jacksonville team in position to be great
5. Roethliesburger - Also on his game this year, a good up from being down last year.
After that, it would be a tossup between Cutler, Young, and Edwards.
"ST21" lanchbury said 12/18, 12:00 AM
i thought about putting garrad at 4 but i think that big ben is better then garrad eaven though garrads team beat big bens dosint mean that garrad is a better QB. i mean u could have the worst team in the NFL say the dolphins and have tom brady on there but that dosint mean hes a bad QB i just means hes on a good team.
i mean u do have to have a good team to be a good QB but still like i sead just cuz garrads team is better dosing mean anything
soxfan10000 said 12/18, 12:22 AM
Actually, I think that Garrard has better control (16 TD/2 INT vs. Ben's 29/11). Furthermore, Garrard's got a 101.6 rating to Ben's 100.5, and while that's not necessarily significant, Garrard has had much better ratings the last few weeks than Ben. Garrard's putting it all together at a time when Ben's just looking really good. So that's why I've got Garrard over Ben.
"ST21" lanchbury said 12/19, 01:10 AM
Forfeited Turn
soxfan10000 said 12/19, 07:45 AM
As for Anderson over the other two, my logic is simply that considering that Anderson has done so much in what could be considered a Drew Brees moment (when you know that you're simply supposed to be the guy that gets you to the next big thing), that his performance is particularly remarkable. I'd say that if Garrard continues his performance at the level he's been at, that he'd move ahead of Anderson at the end of the year.
Faces at the U.S. Open
Terms under which this service is provided to you. Read our privacy guidelines.
© 2008 STATS LLC
Comments (17)
romo doesnt play in the AFC...
and garrard has thrown two INT this season. he is the real deal
xbrokendownx | 12/18/07, 12:02 AM
Report Offensive Commentmy bad. i ment to day it dosint mean hes a bad QB it just means hes on a bad team sorry peoples
"ST21" lanchbury | 12/18/07, 12:02 AM
Report Offensive Commenthe dose to look it up on the internet stupid
"ST21" lanchbury | 12/18/07, 12:03 AM
Report Offensive Commento god he dosint my bad
"ST21" lanchbury | 12/18/07, 12:05 AM
Report Offensive CommentLast time I checked Romo played in the NFC buddy
drgfri | 12/18/07, 01:11 AM
Report Offensive Comment1) Brady
2) Manning
3) Roethlisberger
4) Gerrard
5) Anderson
Robogg | 12/18/07, 03:47 AM
Report Offensive Commentwell i think the cowboys are the best team in the AFC, oh wait, are they they afc southwest? Try NFC. (:
THREE DOLLAR BILL, Y'ALL | 12/18/07, 07:19 AM
Report Offensive Commentthis is perfect material for my dunce award
THREE DOLLAR BILL, Y'ALL | 12/18/07, 07:19 AM
Report Offensive CommentOH MAN TOO FUNNY
smackem | 12/18/07, 08:17 AM
Report Offensive CommentYou don't get my vote because you put Romo!!! cough NFC cough
JTMeek | 12/18/07, 08:55 AM
Report Offensive CommentRobog has the best list - no vote.
T-Fo's Las Vegas-style Show | 12/18/07, 11:03 AM
Report Offensive CommentIf the internet says Romo plays in the AFC it must be true.
FaVre <3's Mr. Rodgers | 12/18/07, 11:29 AM
Report Offensive CommentAccording to the stat that is supposed to encompass the all around play of the quarterback (the QB rating, duh), the list should look like this:
1. Brady
2. Garrard
3. Roethlisberger
4. Manning
5. Cutler
Hoffa The Great | 12/18/07, 11:37 AM
Report Offensive CommentPutting Anderson at number 2 is just absurd. In fact, he shouldn't be there at all. Look at his statistics.
He's 9th out of 17 in the AFC in Rating. He's thrown the 4th most INTs at 14. He's 16th out 17 in completion percentage.
Yes he's 4th in the AFC in TDs and Yards, but his peripherals are not good.
Porkins: Pisses Excellence | 12/18/07, 11:57 AM
Report Offensive CommentFor someone to say Romo plays in the AFC because he read it on the internet trully doesnt know ANYTHING about football. ANYTHING. soxfan, for you to not catch that right away and comment is a shame lol. I vote for you because your list is more accurate but next time, call your opponent out on mistakes.
The Guru hopes to be back soon | 12/18/07, 11:57 AM
Report Offensive Commentpersonall i would say griese at 1, ortton at 2, sean salisbury at 3, ron jaworski at 4, and then probably joe theisman at 5 as my best qb in the afc.
theback21 | 12/19/07, 09:36 AM
Report Offensive CommentCarson Palmer anyone?
Bentley00 - Welcome Schenner | 12/19/07, 09:46 AM
Report Offensive CommentAdd a comment
Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines