FanNation

J (Browns 19-0) Carbathlee said 12/24, 12:30 PM
Well it doesn't say based on this year anywhere so I will guess it just means best players.
PG
Steve Nash
Jason Kidd- Mr. Triple-double *
Chris Paul

SG- Kobe Bryant
Allen Iverson
D-wade

SF
Lebron James
Melo Anthony
Paul Pierce

PF- Kevin Garnett
Tim Duncan* How can you not have Duncan? He is the best PF ever, or one of them.
Dirk Nowitzki

C
Dwight Howard
Yao Ming
Amare Stoudemire

So we are arguing Kidd to Davis and Duncan to Al Jefferson.

Kidd has triple doubles galore and is averaging a monster 10.3 assists per game this season. Kidd is a regular all star selection and is one of the best ball handlers in the NBA. Davis has the better PPG because he is the team. Kidd has talent surrounding him, but Davis basically just has to fire up shots. Kidd almost has 2.5 more assists per game than Davis and close to 4 more rebounds a game so I am willing to give Davis his 11 more points a game because Kidd is a much better leader.

Duncan to Jefferson is pretty hilarious. Duncan is known by many as the best PF ever and some people would scratch their head and say, Who is Al Jefferson? Plus he obviously cant lead a team since he has never been in the playoff

J (Browns 19-0) Carbathlee said 12/24, 12:51 PM
No, you are not talking about this year. That was never in the rules. You said top players, no where did you ever say that you meant this year or based on this season. Plus, technically I would still win. Tim Duncan won a championship this year in 07. Next time if you mean this year include it in your title but don't change it when it is already going.

I am arguing skill wise so put your stats away.

Duncan almost has more rings than Jefferson has years in the NBA. Jefferson has yet to even play in a playoff game so I don't know how you can make him a top 3 player at his position. He isn't even the best player on his team. Duncan is by far the best player on his team and is arguably the best PF ever.

Kidd is just a better ball handler passing and dribbling wise. You can say what you want about Davis' flashy plays and high scoring, but Kidd gets the job done.

J (Browns 19-0) Carbathlee said 12/24, 08:38 PM
Sorry for the delay, I was at a Christmas party.

Let me go over the title for you.

"Top playes in the NBA- name top 3-PGs, SGs, SFs, PFs, and Cs. "

Here is what I am getting from this, top players in the NBA means that they are currently in the NBA so I am following you to this point. Then it just says list them. Top players means best players does it not? You never said anything about this year and you obviously just live in a world of fantasy sports and stats.

Many other players huh? No acctually that is about it. You said the two players that help them and then throw in a quick and many other players. If you would rather have Jefferson as your starting PF than Tim Duncan then you would probably be put in an insane asylum. Its that simple. You never defined this year and it is not implied at all when you say best players. When you say best players I think of skill not a stat sheet.
What is so hard to understand about this?