Community

StLDieHard won the Throwdown.

Da Masta: At camp to july 25

vs

StLDieHard

Throwndowns: 83
Record: 49 - 25 - 9
I live in, NJ
All Throwdowns
9
Votes
Throwndowns: 85
Record: 47 - 33 - 5
St. Louis, MO
All Throwdowns
8
Votes

Poll Dancers finals: Make an NBA allstar team from the Atlantic Division but theres a catch....


Here is the catch, you can only use one player from every team
C- K. Garnett (BOS)
PF- C. Bosh (TOR)
SF- A. Iguodala (PHI)
SG- J. Crawford (NYK)
PG- J. Kidd (NJN)


I wouldnt necessarily call it an all-star team but here we go.

You must of made a mistake on the center position. Garnett is a PF, and I think you know that. Kendrick Perkins plays center for the Celtics... not Garnett. Nice try though. I will let you make changes to your roster because it is the holidays lol. Here is mine, not much of a difference but when you do a TD with this topic.. do you expect them to be different? I dont like the subject because I, basically have no choices, but here it is.

C- Andrea Bargnani
PF- Kevin Garnett
SF- Andre Iguodala
SG- Jamal Crawford
PG- Jason Kidd

arguements ahead...


sorry about Garnett hear is my team:
C- Samuel Dalembert
PF- Zach Randolph
SF- Richard Jefferson
SG- Ray Allen
PG- TJ Ford

Well my team is completely different from yours...
Centers- Dalembert vs. Bargnani
I think that I win here-
Bargnani- 9 ppg. 4 rpg.
Dalembert- 11 ppg. 10 rpg.
Decision- I win
PF's- KG vs. Randolph
KG- 19 pts. 10 rpg
Randolph- 18 ppg. 10 rpg.
Decision- Tie in the stats pretty much but KG is better overall, you win
SF's -Jefferson vs. Iguodala
Iguodala- 19 pts. 5 rpg. 5 apg.
Jefferson- 25 ppg. 5 rpg. 3 apg
Decision- Once again tie in stats but RJ gets much more points, I win
SG's- Allen vs. Crawford
Allen- 19 ppg. 4 rpg. 3 apg.
Crawford- 19 ppg. 3 rpg. 3 apg.
Decision- I win
PG's- Kidd vs. Ford
Kidd- 11 ppg. 10 apg.
Ford- 14 ppg. 7 apg.
Decision- Tie in stats but this is obvious, Kidd is better, you win

OVERALL- I won 3-2


Garnett vs Randolph

asts/game Garnett 4 Randolph 1.6
FG% Garnett 55% Randolph 45%
FT% Garnett 80% Randolph 71%
to/game Garnett 2 Randolph 3.5
stls/game Garnett 2 Randolph 0.8
blks/game Garnett 1.7 Randolph 0.2 (no joke lol)
wins Garnett 26 Randolph 8 (ouch)
Garnett is the MVP so far and the undisputed best PF in the league. Dont even compare him to Zach freaking Randolph.

Kidd vs Ford

rebs/game Kidd 9 Ford 2
asts/game Kidd 11 Ford 6.8
3-pt% Kidd 33% Ford 27%
stl/game Kidd 2 Ford 1
blks/game Kidd 0.5 Ford (hasnt blocked a guy yet)
TJ Ford hasnt played since what? The 12th? Plus (just like Garnett vs Randolph), dont compare these two players. It isnt even right. Jason Kidd is Mr. Triple-Double. How many people can say that?


You may have a better Center, Small Forward, and Shooting Guard... but the guys that I have better than you... are WAY better than you. W-A-Y.


Okay you just compared the guys that I already said that you had won but for your assist per game for Randolph vs. Garnett, remember Garnett passes to Ray Allen and Paul Pierce while Randolph passes to who? Stephon Marbury? Quentin Richardson? Like I said before you win 2 and I win 3. Yes your guys that you won with (Kidd and KG) are much better than the guys I chose for those positions but I dominate for mine that I won in also.
C- Bargnani plays like 10 min. every game now and gets 4 rpg. For a center that sucks compared to Dalemberts stats who gets a double-double every game
SF- Jefferson has better stats playing with other all stars while Iguodala gets worse stats when he is his teams star
SG- Allen has proven over his career that he gets more points than Crawford (he cant now that hes on the Celts), while Crawford has never proven anything.


OVERALL- I DOMINATE IN 3 OF THE POSITIONS WHILE YOU ONLY WIN 2, A.K.A. I WIN!!!!


The last 4 games, Bargnani has started and is averaging 30+ plus minutes in them games. Yet, you say he doesnt start and only plays 10 minutes? Okay....

You compared them guys but you tried hiding the big stats. For example..
"PG's- Kidd vs. Ford
Kidd- 11 ppg. 10 apg.
Ford- 14 ppg. 7 apg."
You hid the fact that Kidd averages 9 rebounds/game compared to Ford's 2!

Plus, you dont even know when Ford will be back. Who knows if he is coming back?! That is like picking Nene from the Nuggets. He is a decent player but he hasnt played a whole lot because he is hurt.. that is stupid.

Crawford hasnt proven anything because he is on the Knicks. I kinda like the Knicks and I watch some games. That kid is good. If he traded places with Ray Allen, I am sure he would be more recgonized. Trust me.

You are a bit confused.

Comments (8)

Most Recent Comment Add Comment RSS

Garnett is a power forward dude...

Report Offensive Comment

yeah KG is not a center. not even on nba live. haha dwight nice td

my vote could sway back though

Report Offensive Comment

i fixed my team it is completly different

Report Offensive Comment

Tough oversight there with Garnett, Masta... interesting choices, but I think that you debated it better than dwight, and pulled through a major gaffe to come out a lot better than I expected...

... and dwight, I think you had a real case to make... then you conceded that 3 of 5 positions were chosen better by Masta... and then tried to backtrack by putting hyphens between the letters in WAY... I think you chose the better team but failed to argue it competently...

SO MY VOTE GOES TO DA MASTA...

Report Offensive Comment

My team is more balanced also

Report Offensive Comment

argueably

Report Offensive Comment
 

Bargnani vs Garnett.

hmmmmm

GARNETT

Report Offensive Comment

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


or cancel

SI.com Photos

Faces at the U.S. Open
Back in Time: September 5
Former Athletes Turned Politicians
Visit SI.com for more photo galleries

SI.com Top 10 Headlines

Visit SI.com for more stories