Truth & Rumors > NCAAF

Alabama St. decision could impact FSU

Views
3759
Comments
78

It turns out Alabama State, which had its five-year probation for, among other things, academic fraud reduced to three on appeal, is serving as one of several lynchpins in Florida State's rebuttal to the NCAA Committee on Infractions' decision to uphold their vacating-of-wins penalty. According to the Tallahassee Democrat, FSU today officially issued their response to the Infraction Appeals Committee, arguing in part that the precedent set by the Alabama State decision, when coupled with their own self-reporting and self-corrective actions in the case, should lead to the victories that have been taken away being returned.

NBC Sports

Bobby Bowden, AP Bobby Bowden, AP
July 2, 2009  11:25 AM ET

5 years to 3? That's not a complete overturn. That's a reduction. Maybe FSU should get 40% of it's wins returned. Instead of 14 football wins lost, they only lose 8.4 wins.

This is becoming ridiculous.

July 2, 2009  11:31 AM ET

Gotta give me one thing, they have certainly circled the wagons for Bowden. Wonder if they know how bad it's making them look.

July 2, 2009  11:38 AM ET
QUOTE(#2):

Wonder if they know how bad it's making them look.

I doubt it. This is embarrassingly stupid. We need to man-up, take our medicine, and MOVE ON!

July 2, 2009  11:46 AM ET
QUOTE(#2):

Gotta give me one thing, they have certainly circled the wagons for Bowden. Wonder if they know how bad it's making them look.

can't be as bad as going out to provo and losing to byu. (sept. 19) its not looking good for fsu or miami to start the season, FSU (1-3) and Miami (0-4)

July 2, 2009  11:56 AM ET
QUOTE(#4):

can't be as bad as going out to provo and losing to byu. (sept. 19) its not looking good for fsu or miami to start the season, FSU (1-3) and Miami (0-4)

You think FSU is going to lose to Jacksonville State?

July 2, 2009  12:03 PM ET
QUOTE(#5):

You think FSU is going to lose to Jacksonville State?

I thought i read somewhere that J St was 8-3... FSU better not take them lightly lol...

I dont think BB or TK care... since they will be gone next year

July 2, 2009  12:14 PM ET
QUOTE(#1):

5 years to 3? That's not a complete overturn. That's a reduction. Maybe FSU should get 40% of it's wins returned. Instead of 14 football wins lost, they only lose 8.4 wins. This is becoming ridiculous.

5 years to 3 is like having a reduction from a DD cup to a C cup. UNACCEPTABLE.

July 2, 2009  12:15 PM ET

Looks like JoePa will forever pwn Bobby Bowden when it comes to career wins...woooooo!!!!

July 2, 2009  12:15 PM ET

Give Bobby his wins. Vacating wins is such a lame a-s-s way to punish a school. Unless JoePa dies before 2011, there is no way Bobby is going to catch him anyway. JoePa has a 3-year deal and Bobby will have to pack his bags in 2. There is no way FSU will pay Jimbo $5 million to keep Bobby around one more year. Let's just move on with this already.

July 2, 2009  12:17 PM ET
QUOTE(#5):

You think FSU is going to lose to Jacksonville State?

Of course not. Seth is just stirring the pot somewhat with a little trash talk. By UF/UM/FSU standards, it's fairly mild.

July 2, 2009  12:17 PM ET
QUOTE(#4):

can't be as bad as going out to provo and losing to byu. (sept. 19) its not looking good for fsu or miami to start the season, FSU (1-3) and Miami (0-4)

I don't see that at all. I think FSU starts the season 4-0. I really think FSU will be a lot better than last year. But, I guess we won't know until the season finally comes.

July 2, 2009  12:20 PM ET

I do think it is very possible that Miami starts 0-4 and Shannon's seat will be very hot...

At Florida State
Georgia Tech
At Virginia Tech
Oklahoma

July 2, 2009  12:22 PM ET
QUOTE(#5):

You think FSU is going to lose to Jacksonville State?

should have read fsu (1-3 or 2-2) miami (1-3 or 0-4)

July 2, 2009  12:25 PM ET

Problem is, now the lawyers have their hooks in the situation, and you'd have to gnaw their arms off to get them to let go. Trouble.

July 2, 2009  12:27 PM ET
QUOTE(#11):

I don't see that at all. I think FSU starts the season 4-0. I really think FSU will be a lot better than last year. But, I guess we won't know until the season finally comes.

don't know, they have miami and jax. st. but ponder is still making mistakes and the o-line still has to prove themselves, no to mention who is going to catch the ball. still a lot of questions to be answered, dakota watson (lb) ran a faster 40 than half of the wideouts. and who is going to be in the starting secondary/at running back.

(W) Miami
(W) Jacksonville St.
(L) BYU
(L) South Florida

July 2, 2009  12:36 PM ET

It's just stupid to vacate wins. It doesn't do anything really. Penalizing (scholarships and post season ban) the next few years matters. Why take away the wins? The only way I can see that being fair is if Bowden knew all of the cheating was going on. But hey. Who knows? Maybe he did.

July 2, 2009  12:48 PM ET
QUOTE(#16):

It's just stupid to vacate wins. It doesn't do anything really. Penalizing (scholarships and post season ban) the next few years matters. Why take away the wins? The only way I can see that being fair is if Bowden knew all of the cheating was going on. But hey. Who knows? Maybe he did.

I agree. If you want to penalize a program do it for current and future things, not past.

July 2, 2009  01:08 PM ET
QUOTE(#15):

dakota watson (lb) ran a faster 40 than half of the wideouts. and who is going to be in the starting secondary/at running back.

WR Bert Reed - 4.3, WR Louis Givens - 4.31, WR Richard Goodman 4.34.

LB Dekoda Watson - 4.39, LB Nigel Bradham - 4.48, LB Maurice Harris - 4.48.

Our receivers aren't slow. Our linebackers are fast. Our offense is good, our defense is better. We'll be fine as long as our administrators pull their heads out of their rectums and give up this idiotic appeal.

July 2, 2009  01:08 PM ET

"Bailiff! Whack his pee pee!"

 
July 2, 2009  02:15 PM ET

Coming from out West where we couldn't care much less who you southeastern schools think you are, it is laughable to watch the FSU president prostitute himself for the sake of saving wins for his coach. Anyone but Bowden and this would have been a no contest, no care, let's get on with it affair. To intimate that it is otherwise is an insult to even the dumbest person's intelligence. I don't know who the bigger fool is - FSU or the NCAA. The current arguments, if extrapolated to all other schools, would have the NCAA handing out no sanctions whatsoever since they would be affecting kids who played no part in past wrongdoings. It may be too bad that innocents are hurt by the actions of others, but get over it people - this is real life where that happens everyday.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Stub Hub

The 2009 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Sources: Big Ben having second thoughts
    Views
    6586
    Comments
    908
  2. 2
    Report: Halladay would welcome Yankees trade
    Views
    24292
    Comments
    466
  3. 3
    Have Irish already offered Kelly job?
    Views
    31460
    Comments
    73
  4. 4
    Stoops to take Notre Dame job?
    Views
    3480
    Comments
    57
  5. 5
    Report: Tiger's injuries inflicted by wife
    Views
    1185
    Comments
    54

Throwdowns

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Chico 2.0
  2. 2
    BBK - Now it's all football
  3. 3
    rstowe
  4. 4
    gigi_iv
  5. 5
    Never NDing Struggle

Message Boards

  1. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Your team sucks
    Views
    784
    Replies
    35
  2. NFL > Pittsburgh Steelers

    STEELERS VS RAVENS …
    Views
    277
    Replies
    60
  3. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    CFB Game Day 11/28/2009
    Views
    212
    Replies
    39

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos