Truth & Rumors > MLB

One-time MVP candidate fading fast

Views
29840
Comments
30

08:12 AM ET 08.27 | The boo birds came out Sunday at PNC Park, with the ire aimed at Erik Bedard. That's 16 runs in Bedard's past three starts. I could go after the lineup's laughable lack of discipline, too. Mark Rogers, the 26-year-old Milwaukee pitcher recycled from the minors in July, somehow got away with flailing 101 pitches over five innings. ... I could pick on many individuals digging this offensive hole, led off by the Pirates' two best. Neil Walker has four hits in 37 at-bats since that 5-for-5 gem Aug. 12. Andrew McCutchen, now clinging to his MVP candidacy, is at .185 in the past 16 games. Back-to-back in the order Sunday, they went 0 for 9. Sorry, not good enough. Not when the games count most.

Pittsburgh Tribune-Review

Andrew McCutchen, Icon Sports Andrew McCutchen, Icon Sports
August 27, 2012  09:05 AM ET

The Bucs are fading again this season, but are on the right track of being a 500 or better ball team soon. McCutchen chances of winning the MVP were slim anyway if the Bucs don't make the playoffs.

August 27, 2012  09:12 AM ET

Melky Cabrera should not be able to win a batting title this season after being suspended for using a performance enhancing drug.

August 27, 2012  09:28 AM ET

They couldn't have picked a worse time to go into a team batting slump.

Comment #4 has been removed
August 27, 2012  11:22 AM ET

in a way the pirates aren't to convenced about their goals towards the title shot,,,McCUTCHEN it seems as the roids effect its vanishing to quick and it appears to show he's lack of stamina in this month,,,

August 27, 2012  11:24 AM ET

the pirates player shouldn't feel so bad, mike trout himself its feeling the heat and pressure from all over the angles,,,,

August 27, 2012  11:24 AM ET

the pirates player shouldn't feel so bad, mike trout himself its feeling the heat and pressure from all over the angles,,,,

August 27, 2012  11:25 AM ET

had a guy rambling all season how cutch was MVP lock.....you need to be on a tear through august heading into the labor day weekend where ball games will be in prime time....then seal the deal w/ an consistent september when your team is hitting the home stretch into the playoffs.

doesn't look like cutch or the pirates will be doing either.

August 27, 2012  12:12 PM ET

Wow, it's August and Bedard isn't on the DL. Pretty amazing

August 27, 2012  12:32 PM ET

cutch hasnt been the same since homerun derby. pulling off on everthing , when going good he was hitting balls hard to right center and right

August 27, 2012  12:33 PM ET

cutch went down hill after homerun derby. pulling off on too many pitches. when he hit good everything was left center right center

August 27, 2012  01:07 PM ET

The Pirates August swooon is quickly turning the season from a playoff hunt into a hold on to stay above .500 hunt.

August 27, 2012  01:08 PM ET
QUOTE(#5):

in a way the pirates aren't to convenced about their goals towards the title shot,,,McCUTCHEN it seems as the roids effect its vanishing to quick and it appears to show he's lack of stamina in this month,,,

Wrong McCutchen!

That was Daniel not Andrew who got suspened fpr PED.

August 27, 2012  01:09 PM ET

*for

August 27, 2012  01:16 PM ET

I would like to see the MLB actually take a stand about HGH and PEDS I am beggining to lean towards 0 tollarence. You test positive your gonefor good, you give up where you got em then your only on a 5 year suspension.

August 27, 2012  01:27 PM ET

It's not quite to the point of "holding on" to staying above .500, they're still 9 games over .500 and have 13 of their final 35 against the Cubs and the Astros. They only have to play .400 baseball to finish 82-80 which is only slightly better than the .375 winning percentage they've posted in a terrible August during which they've had a much harder schedule than they have the rest of the way.

While it is disappointing to see them stumble to the finish line, their realistic timeline for being a playoff contender is still 2 years away and they've shown tremendous improvement in just the past 2 seasons. If they improve as much over the next 2 seasons as they have the last 2 then you're looking at the 2014 NL Central champs.

August 27, 2012  01:30 PM ET
QUOTE(#16):

It's not quite to the point of "holding on" to staying above .500, they're still 9 games over .500 and have 13 of their final 35 against the Cubs and the Astros. They only have to play .400 baseball to finish 82-80 which is only slightly better than the .375 winning percentage they've posted in a terrible August during which they've had a much harder schedule than they have the rest of the way. While it is disappointing to see them stumble to the finish line, their realistic timeline for being a playoff contender is still 2 years away and they've shown tremendous improvement in just the past 2 seasons. If they improve as much over the next 2 seasons as they have the last 2 then you're looking at the 2014 NL Central champs.

Well said.

August 27, 2012  02:01 PM ET

why are we pirates always 2 years away or 3 years away? mangement should spend the millions there making at the gate for quality players . not the bedards or correias, barajas barmes. need to make good decisios to help the walkers , cutch, marte, jones, burnett. they need to quit signing players for 1 year fixes. look at trade deadline, wandy, gaby and qualls , they done nothing to help. only good move was marte promotion and he might be a year away

August 27, 2012  02:45 PM ET
QUOTE(#18):

why are we pirates always 2 years away or 3 years away? mangement should spend the millions there making at the gate for quality players . not the bedards or correias, barajas barmes. need to make good decisios to help the walkers , cutch, marte, jones, burnett. they need to quit signing players for 1 year fixes. look at trade deadline, wandy, gaby and qualls , they done nothing to help. only good move was marte promotion and he might be a year away

Know the feeling.

Signed,

A Jays Fan

 
August 27, 2012  04:03 PM ET

wiseup: Its apparent as A. McCuthen goes so goes the Pirates. Most managers will tell you one player cannot carry the team. Since The All-Star game M cCuthen has dropped from .373 To present .343 The Pirates have lost 7 games in thestanding. Some Writers predicted the Reds Would al;so fall in standings without Votto in the lineup. However to the reds credit other teammates have stepped up and held together. It seemed like every night it was somebody different getting the clutch hit or having a big game.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Rihanna outs Smith's hard-partying ways
    Views
    10858
    Comments
    1073
  2. 2
    Steinbrenner believes in less-expensive Yanks
    Views
    13802
    Comments
    431
  3. 3
    Carlyle haunted by Game 7 regrets
    Views
    3901
    Comments
    123
  4. 4
    Bard's career nearing precipice
    Views
    1799
    Comments
    70
  5. 5
    Calipari's NCAA rant: 'We need to separate'
    Views
    17561
    Comments
    62

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos