Golden Tate: I Pushed Off

It's impossible for him to have made a simultaneous catch. There is indisputable evidence that the Packers receiver was the first to have hands on the ball. He brought it to his chest, he landed with possession, and at no point did he lose possession.

"Simultaneous" means exactly what it sounds like .... both players make contact with the ball the exact the same time, and both players land with both hands on that ball.

Just because Tate got his hands on it in the air, it doesn't matter. The Packers defender was already in the process of claiming sole possession. It doesn't matter how many hands end up on the ball before the play is whistled dead... it matters who touches it first, and whether or not that person completes all of the necessary requirements to make a completion.

The bottom line, GB got robber. It should have been a touchback, GB's ball at their own 20.

And that's not even factoring in the offensive pass interference, which should have ended the play then and there.

Thank god the real refs are coming back next week.

Call was correct. Jennings never touched both feet or any of his body after "catching" the ball. Tate has both feet on the ground and has his hands wrapped around the ball along with Jennings, but again since Jennings still hasn't touched the ground with both his feet or a part of his body, by rule he hasn't caught the ball yet, Tate does. Why the so-called "Experts" don't see this is perhaps because we're talking the Packers not the Browns etc.... Proof is there people, the rules are specific. I don't care really care about the PI, that wasn't called and again the so-called "experts" said that always happens and isn't called.

QUOTE(#2):

Originally posted 06:32 AM ET  09.27 by jayman419

It's impossible for him to have made a simultaneous catch. There is indisputable evidence that the Packers receiver was the first to have hands on the ball. He brought it to his chest, he landed with possession, and at no point did he lose possession."Simultaneous" means exactly what it sounds like .... both players make contact with the ball the exact the same time, and both players land with both hands on that ball. Just because Tate got his hands on it in the air, it doesn't matter. The Packers defender was already in the process of claiming sole possession. It doesn't matter how many hands end up on the ball before the play is whistled dead... it matters who touches it first, and whether or not that person completes all of the necessary requirements to make a completion.The bottom line, GB got robber. It should have been a touchback, GB's ball at their own 20. And that's not even factoring in the offensive pass interference, which should have ended the play then and there.Thank god the real refs are coming back next week.

Call was correct. Jennings never touched both feet or any of his body after "catching" the ball. Tate has both feet on the ground and has his hands wrapped around the ball along with Jennings, but again since Jennings still hasn't touched the ground with both his feet or a part of his body, by rule he hasn't caught the ball yet, Tate does. Why the so-called "Experts" don't see this is perhaps because we're talking the Packers not the Browns etc.... Proof is there people, the rules are specific. I don't care really care about the PI, that wasn't called and again the so-called "experts" said that always happens and isn't called.