Truth & Rumors > MLB

Is Mike Piazza headed to Cooperstown?


05:03 AM ET 12.18 | This is a crazy year for Baseball Writers of America Association voters for the Hall. The first-timers on the ballot include Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens and Sammy Sosa. None of them ever served a suspension for taking performance-enhancing drugs, but considerable smoke has surrounded their careers and others have said that they did. The ballot is also cluttered with Rafael Palmeiro, who was suspended, and Mark McGwire, who later admitted taking the banned substances. Many voters have indicated they are torn about what to do. Many others have indicated they won't vote for any player who in their minds is in any way tainted. It takes a 75 percent approval rating among the 600 or so voters to be elected to the Hall, so just what will happen when the polls close Dec. 31 is a mystery. But one of the many questions facing baseball writers is whether or not Mike Piazza is worthy of a bust in Cooperstown.

Call To The Pen

Mike Piazza, AP Photo/Chris Gardner Mike Piazza, AP Photo/Chris Gardner
Comment #1 has been removed
December 18, 2012  10:42 PM ET

I think he'll slide by.

December 19, 2012  12:21 AM ET

Hell, yes, Piazza is headed to Cooperstown.

Is he? Depends on if he took any steriods. I already lost track of who did and who didn't

December 19, 2012  12:36 AM ET

IF he took steroids?lol...You mean WHEN. Try the Mexican League in 1991 and probably earlier than that and then onward for many years. He's a great example of a guy who would have probably been a career Double or Triple A player but the juice helped him with his strength, confidence and ability to bounce back. It's a shame because he seemed like a great guy and was always great to us Mets fans but I heard stories about him for years. He's probably in the Mitchell report by the way.

December 19, 2012  04:29 AM ET

Is he? Depends on if he took any steriods. I already lost track of who did and who didn't

Someone only read half the post.

December 19, 2012  04:42 AM ET

Someone only read half the post.

Yes. Yes they did.

Comment #7 has been removed
Comment #8 has been removed
December 19, 2012  05:01 AM ET

He's the greatest offensive catcher possibly ever. He'll get in.

Hated seeing him go to the east coast.

Comment #10 has been removed
December 19, 2012  05:09 AM ET

Me too. Especially into the Phillies division. He's a local so I always pulled for him. But it was alot harder to root for him in a Met's uni.

Wouldn't have bothered me so much if he'd gone to Philly. But to any of those teams northeast of you? Crappenhammer.

Comment #12 has been removed
December 19, 2012  05:18 AM ET

I like the way you think. It was kind of an odd turn of events as I remember it. Wasn't he a Marlin for like 3 days between Dodgers and Mets? Granted the Marlins are still a division foe, but would have been much less inner conflict if he had just stayed there.

I'd forgotten about that. Yeah, upon checking, he actually played 5 games for the Marlins before going to the Mets. At my age, even all these years after Curt Flood, it is still hard to grasp the business end of all the player movement.

Comment #14 has been removed
December 19, 2012  11:39 AM ET

not roids user??then he is in, but if he use the roids? likely out just like every other cheater player,,,

December 19, 2012  11:58 AM ET

mike piazza all the way home!!!

December 19, 2012  01:46 PM ET


December 19, 2012  10:28 PM ET


He was also a good defensive catcher. When he caught for the Dodgers, LA lead the league in staff ERA (Mets were 3rd I think); when he moved to NY, NY lead the league. The crap about "not throwing runners out" is because the Mets teach their pitchers not to worry about the men on base, but to concentrate on getting the batter out. This is the correct approach, but it puts a lot of strain on the catcher--and the Mets proceeded to hint that the stolen bases were exclusively the catcher's fault. It was actually the result of an organizational decision, and they just decided to make the catcher the scapegoat.

I think he deserves hall of fame--and yes, so does Yogi!

December 19, 2012  10:30 PM ET

Is he? Depends on if he took any steriods. I already lost track of who did and who didn't

Frank Thomas didn't.

Comment #20 has been removed


Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.

Truth & Rumors


  1. 1
    Bryant headed back to Germany
  2. 2
    Shakeup looms for White Sox
  3. 3
    Kerr 'absolutely expects' Knicks offer
  4. 4
    Lightning may be swept aside
  5. 5
    Leonsis leaves coach, GM twisting

SI Photos