FanNation

Of course he denied it. What did you expect him to say??

'Aw....geez. Ya caught me guys!...'

Not that I'm saying that I know, believe, assume, etc that he did or didn't. I just don't think that anyone would be dumb enough to admit it if it came up in question.

At_Home@Wrigley | 04/07/08, 06:44 AM

Rick Honeycutt- professional pine tar identifier. Because it would be impossible for it to be anything else. Like...I don't know...dirt?

Porkins | 04/07/08, 08:00 AM

Yeah dirt that is stuck to his fingers from using pine tar....

Maddux | 04/07/08, 08:20 AM

Rick Honeycutt- professional pine tar identifier. Because it would be impossible for it to be anything else. Like...I don't know...dirt?

Porkins *BS/CB | 04/07/08, 08:00 AM

He's been in the game forever, I trust his knowledge of it.

Hi, I'm Troy McClure | 04/07/08, 08:22 AM

Since modern day cheating (steriods/HGH) is being monitored so closely, maybe guys are resorting to some old fashioned cheating (pine tar, scuffed balls, spitters).

METS4LIFE | 04/07/08, 08:43 AM

Why are people making a big deal out of this incident, but it was no big deal 2 years ago when Kenny Rogers clearly had pine tar on his hands.

bigzz | 04/07/08, 08:51 AM

Let the "Forgot to wash his hands after taking a crap" jokes begin.

Wanted Man | 04/07/08, 08:52 AM

Buut jeez, what is up with Hoffman? Another day, another blown save.

Wanted Man | 04/07/08, 08:57 AM

Why are people making a big deal out of this incident, but it was no big deal 2 years ago when Kenny Rogers clearly had pine tar on his hands.
bigzz | 04/07/08, 08:51 AM
Report Offensive Comment


actually, everyone made a huge deal about it, it was a playoff game....

Nomarfan: Vacation | 04/07/08, 09:32 AM

but in his defense, it was extremely cold, and harder to grip the ball, what's Peavy's excuse?

Nomarfan: Vacation | 04/07/08, 09:33 AM

actually, everyone made a huge deal about it, it was a playoff game....
Nomarfan: Royale with Cheese | 04/07/08, 09:32 AM

So what happened to Kenny or the Tigers? That's right nothing, and being in a playoff game something should have happened.

bigzz | 04/07/08, 09:38 AM

C'mon! Cheating? Hey, Gotta stick up for Peav, he's on my fantasy team!

CanofOil...FanNation Judge | 04/07/08, 09:45 AM

I would accuse too if I got pimp slapped around by this guy 6 times a year.

Field Marshall Sunny Day | 04/07/08, 10:01 AM

I love it (just like the Kenny Rogers thing in the WS) that people like to claim things they can't prove and then the media jumps all over it. The picture doesn't prove anything. So now, since this guy decides he's gonna claim Peavy was using Pine Tar, the media jumps on it and everyone thinks it's true. Of course, there is no way to prove it at this point but who cares. It's a juicy story, and there are a bunch of idiots out there reading it thinking, oh yeah, it must be true because it was printed on SI.com!

Salukibball | 04/07/08, 10:36 AM

Wouldnt suprise me. He doesnt do anything out of the ordinary to warrant the complete domination he has had these past few years unless you add in something like pine tar, then everything starts to make sense.

Cassidy's House: Chin Music | 04/07/08, 10:37 AM

let the whining of the losers begin! now that Honeycutt has planted the seed, Peavy won't have to do a thing -- he's won the psychological game. somewhere the oldtimers like Niekro are smiling broadly

silverblack23 | 04/07/08, 10:40 AM

Back in the day, the Padres used to accuse Don Sutton of the same stuff..... oh yeah, that's right, Sutton did scuff, cut, grease and pine tar the ball. Where there's smoke, there's fire!

Sir Robin (as himself) | 04/07/08, 11:05 AM

I thought that there was something on his fingers when they showed the highlights on ESPN. Nothing you can do about it now, but the photos definitely weren't doctored. Go back and look at the video. It's pretty obvious that he has something on his fingers.

wtnelson | 04/07/08, 11:27 AM

Never mind asking Honeycutt , the real expert on pine tar issues is George Brett .

Hub Man | 04/07/08, 12:32 PM

that explains why they weren't swept.....

mic' | 04/07/08, 12:37 PM