Truth & Rumors > NHL

Promo_BaseballChallenge_638x30

Rangers interested in ex-Penguin

Views
236
Comments
-3

The Rangers, we're told, are among a select number of teams interested in former Penguins defenseman Josef Melichar, who played this season in the Swedish Elite League. A physical-oriented defenseman who will turn 30 in January, Melichar probably can be signed for approximately $1M. So, are the Blueshirts better off with a combined $6M investment in Michal Rozsival and projected third-pair defenseman Melichar, or with a combined $6.5-7M investment in Brooks Orpik and, say, impending Montreal free agent Mark Streit, who would play on the third pair and on the vacated power-play point?

New York Post

Glen Sather, Getty Images Glen Sather, Getty Images
June 8, 2008  11:46 PM ET

Glen Sather, proud owner of 'Glamour Shots' franchise at the Manhattan Park plaza.

June 9, 2008  07:52 AM ET

Let them waste money on Melichar.

June 9, 2008  08:30 AM ET

If they can get Streit and Orpik that would be the way to go, I'd rather spend the extra cash on a couple of guys who were actually in the league last year and had decent seasons rather than a guy that played in the Swedish Elte League. Not taking anything away from the SEL but it's not the NHL.

June 9, 2008  08:44 AM ET

Detroit seems to have done alright with their picks from the swedish elite league.

June 9, 2008  09:16 AM ET

How many 30 year olds have they got from the SEL.

June 9, 2008  09:48 AM ET

Let them waste money on Melichar.

DurkDiggler | 06/09/08, 07:52 AM
=============

Um...the point of the article is that if they were to go for Melichar as the low-cost option to more expensive defensemen, while he is basically AS talented as anyone they can get - and then sign a more dynamic offensive player or retain Rozsival- the Rangers would be better off. Its not a waste of money at $1 million. You should read the article.

June 9, 2008  10:26 AM ET

What's up with the Rangers going after so many former Penguins? Rozsival is a former Pen, Melichar is too. Add in Jagr and Straka. Then the article talks about the Rangers looking at Orpik and Hossa.

June 9, 2008  10:28 AM ET

"Let them waste money on Melichar.

DurkDiggler | 06/09/08, 07:52 AM
Report Offensive Comment
"

1 million? LOL hardly a waste. Hater.

June 9, 2008  10:46 AM ET

Let's see, he wasn't good enough to stay on the Pens. He wasn't good enough to be in the NHL last season. But now he is being talked about like he is some suprise bargin that is going to put the team in a better cap position. 1Mil is more than he is worth. So I repeat my statement, Let the Penguins rejects... I mean Rangers waste their money on him.

June 9, 2008  10:47 AM ET

"What's up with the Rangers going after so many former Penguins? Rozsival is a former Pen, Melichar is too. Add in Jagr and Straka. Then the article talks about the Rangers looking at Orpik and Hossa.

gjb140 | 06/09/08, 10:26 AM
Report Offensive Comment
"

Jagr also played for the Caps. And Straka was on the Devils for a good while. Melichar now plays in Sweden. Mark Streit wasn't a Pen but he's on the Canadians. I think you're on to something! IDK what though...

June 9, 2008  10:49 AM ET

"So I repeat my statement, Let the Penguins rejects... I mean Rangers waste their money on him.

DurkDiggler | 06/09/08, 10:46 AM
Report Offensive Comment
"

Penguin rejects LOL. You're just bitter you thought the Pensys actually had a chance at winning the Cup. Let the crying divers overpay Malkin or Hossa this was their best chance to win the Cup and they blew it. Even with the refs blowing their whistles giving them powerplays every period.

June 9, 2008  11:21 AM ET

Brooks Orpik we know but, Joseph .... who?

June 9, 2008  11:33 AM ET

LOL, how does making a comment about a former Pens player make me Bitter? I'm not bitter that they lost, they got out coached and were out played. They will be back. Perhaps it is you that is bitter, going on the offensive anyone says anything remotely negative about your precious Rangers.

June 9, 2008  11:43 AM ET

OtherOne...are you still on the diving thing?

June 9, 2008  12:10 PM ET

Sorry Durk it isn't you. I have too many people around me who claim to be Pens fans (when I know more about their team than the do) knowing very little or nothing of hockey and think it's clever to call the Rangers "Penguins rejects."

They seem to not understand that players don't stick to their teams for their entire careers out of goodwill. Or free agency.

"OtherOne...are you still on the diving thing?

Therrien Rocks | 06/09/08, 11:43 AM
Report Offensive Comment
"

Therrien, sorry for speaking the forbidden word.

June 9, 2008  12:11 PM ET

"What's up with the Rangers going after so many former Penguins?"

It appears Slats likes the Penguins success over the last 15 years! LOL!

June 9, 2008  12:21 PM ET

As a long time pittsburgh fan, im telling all of you that Melichar is a joke. TRUST ME. Orpik is what all of you want, im gonna be very disappointed to see him leave

June 9, 2008  12:33 PM ET

1 million... a deal.

June 9, 2008  02:00 PM ET

PLEASE SIGN MELICHAR! CROSBY AND MALKIN WILL HAVE A FIELD DAY WITH THAT BUM! CROSBY MIGHT NOT EVEN HAVE TO DIVE ANYMORE! JEALOUS RANGERS FANS GET WHAT YOU DESERVE...MELICHAR!!!!

 
June 9, 2008  02:09 PM ET

PLEASE SIGN MELICHAR! CROSBY AND MALKIN WILL HAVE A FIELD DAY WITH THAT BUM! CROSBY MIGHT NOT EVEN HAVE TO DIVE ANYMORE! JEALOUS RANGERS FANS GET WHAT YOU DESERVE...MELICHAR!!!!

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Stub Hub

The 2009 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Browns owner chasing Holmgren?
    Views
    20822
    Comments
    1672
  2. 2
    Who will play shortstop for Red Sox?
    Views
    22956
    Comments
    1308
  3. 3
    Navy loss a deal-breaker for Weis?
    Views
    44126
    Comments
    336
  4. 4
    Patriots show up Porter
    Views
    21321
    Comments
    280
  5. 5
    Kobe's contract extension on hold
    Views
    23810
    Comments
    154

Throwdowns

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Porkins: F U to Hell, BCS
  2. 2
    RobertMenn: You stole my rake
  3. 3
    Perfectpats
  4. 4
    sign here
  5. 5
    Oso: Informative Sports. com

Message Boards

  1. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    tSlowsu is still a joke! So is…
    Views
    243
    Replies
    70
  2. NFL > General NFL

    terminology
    Views
    124
    Replies
    56
  3. MMA > General MMA

    Strikeforce Fedor vs Rogers…
    Views
    94
    Replies
    32

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos