FanNation - The Republic of Sport

Cuddyer and Hernandez for a third baseman? Who exactly? Any ideas?

Livan's a bum.

Twins fan - I actually much prefer the threads that are NOT about the Red Sox or Yankees.

Yeah, I'd be interested to know who they are looking at among 3rd basemen.

I'm surprised that they would want to move a veteran like Livan, and all his PO experience when they are only a couple of games back. I know he hasn't had a great year, but I thought he had pitched pretty well in his last 3-4 starts.

back to the marlins he goes to replace andrew miller

Who would actually take Hernandez???? And how exactly does Cuddyer sweeten any deal....What exactly has he done??? Who is he?? The Twins might as well offer a few used batting practice balls and some of Joe Mauers used razors and club house towels...That would bascially be the same as offering Hernanzez and Cuddyer.

Though I highly doubt the Twins will trade Hernandez with their postseason chances right now (especially after the Castillo debacle last season), I think the most likely scenarios would be to trade Hernandez and Cuddyer to either Colorado for Atkins and a minor leaguer or to Seattle for Beltre. The Twins were interested in Atkins in the offseason last year, so I would think they'd be on him again should it all come to that.
However, the overall most ideal situation I can think of would be to hold onto Hernandez and Cuddyer, bump Bass out of the bullpen and back into the minors (or release him, as I think he's out of options), bump Liriano into the bullpen and finish the season that way. Then, at the end of the season, let Hernandez walk and move Liriano to the rotation and bring up someone like Humber or maybe Mulvey to replace him in the bullpen. And while we're into shuffling things around, release Everett and Lamb and save a few bucks. Punto, Harris, Casilla and Buscher have proven they're skilled enough to handle the left side of the infield...
But please oh please, Mr. Smith...DON'T TRADE CUDDYER!!!!!!!

The Twins could pull a Tanya Harding / Nancy Kerrigan incident on Hernandez....that would open up a spot for Lariano... Because everyone in the league knows he has NO trade value...

I don't think I could get use to a guy who is in constant "slow motion" - including his fastball !!!

Twins Fan - I guess you are right on him being the most likely candidate. It just seems to me that Livan is the kind of guy you want around for a pennant race.

Livan has the wins, but his ERA and BB ratio are both horrible. He is one bad start from becoming a glaring liability.

The Twins should definitely sell high now. The rotation is already solid and, very quietly, Francisco Liriano has been lights out in AAA (7-0 in his last 8 starts - 24 K's, 0 runs in his last 21 innings).

Oh, free advice: those of you playing fantasy baseball, check to see if Liriano's available on the waiver wire. You stand to benefit.

Livan i can see but not Cuddy.

I'd love to see the Twins get rid of Livan, he's a bum. Cuddy is a good player though but has been injured all season (see finger injury). I highly doubt the Twins get rid of Cuddy because Span has played well for 3 weeks. Not to mention I'm not sure who would be dumb enough to want Livan.

The Twins have to trade Hernandez for anything. He is due to make another $2 million dollars if he pitches 200 innings or more. Cuddy had a good year last year and should have some trade value. He is an above average defender with an excellent arm. I see why they want to trade him with Span hitting and playing as well as he has. I see the Twins ending up with either Beltre or Atkins. Both teams are selling right now and Hernandez is done after this year. Beltre is overpaid and that would help Seattle clear some money to sign free agents this offseason.