FanNation - The Republic of Sport

1

he was better as a cardinal..with pujols

Are the Cardinals aware that he can only move 3 feet to either side?

Maybe they want to try him at second. I'd be open to that; but, I'd rather keep Izturiz at short instead of putting Renteria there. At least Izturiz plays a fine shortstop. Edgar's best fielding days are behind him. You have to have a good shortstop when your pitching coach preaches pitching down in the zone to contact.

QUOTE(#3):

Originally posted 07:19 AM ET  11.03 by TGRFAN1

Are the Cardinals aware that he can only move 3 feet to either side?

And his batting average drops 3 points every at bat?

This dog won't hunt. Edgar will be a liability defensively and pitching should be the greatest concern not getting a washed up middle infielder.

QUOTE(#3):

Originally posted 07:19 AM ET  11.03 by TGRFAN1

Are the Cardinals aware that he can only move 3 feet to either side?

That might be too generous.....he's got the lateral movement of Stephen Hawking

The most concerning part of the article is the Cards remaining in a holding pattern on starting pitching to evaluate Carpenter. Get another quality starter NOW. There are worse things to have than an extra starting pitcher - not having enough starting pitchers is far worse. The odds of Carpenter ever coming back as a dominate pitcher are extremely slim. Replace him. If he does come back, consider it a bonus.

I don't want Edgar back........his time as a Cardinal has passed, and I agree that I would rather see Izturis defensively, with Lopez coming back to play second.

Wow.......that's some serious dis-like

QUOTE(#7):

Originally posted 08:44 AM ET  11.03 by The TRUTH

That might be too generous.....he's got the lateral movement of Stephen Hawking

so what you're really saying is he's a FAST Paul Konerko?

he belongs in the national league...he can't make it in the American League

most prolific regular season?! who cares about that. they won a championship in '06. I think they'd have a Championship with an 83-79 record rather than an 86 win season that brought them 4th place.

On 11/4:

The tall, skinny brother with the smooth jumper.

QUOTE(#15):

Originally posted 07:44 PM ET  11.03 by A Good-Looking Man

On 11/4:The tall, skinny brother with the smooth jumper.

Nice to see you, handsome.

QUOTE(#15):

Originally posted 07:44 PM ET  11.03 by A Good-Looking Man

On 11/4:The tall, skinny brother with the smooth jumper.

You want us to vote for Tayshaun Prince?

QUOTE(#17):

Originally posted 08:50 PM ET  11.03 by TenRingsSTL

You want us to vote for Tayshaun Prince?

I thought he was talking about Cuba Gooding Junior.

If the Sox miss out on Tex then theres this kid named Lars Anderson in the farm that could come up and be a big factor...

Renteria jump a little lighter,
Edgarita come sit by the Card's fire,
St. Louis wants to be your love, ain't no lie,
Edgarita you're they're stone desire.........