Truth & Rumors > MLB

Pettitte's mystery offer

Views
4911
Comments
60

05:38 AM ET 12.16 | It's been a mystery to many why veteran left-hander Andy Pettitte hasn't taken the Yankees' $10-million offer. But here could be a clue as to why he hasn't: Pettitte's people apparently are telling folks he has a $36-million, three-year offer from another, unnamed team. Pettitte, who didn't return SI's calls regarding his reputed offer, has been the Yankees' first choice for their final rotation spot after reaching agreements with high-priced free-agent stars CC Sabathia and A.J. Burnett for $243.5 million in total. But it isn't believed that this $36-million claim has moved the Yankees to change their offer by even one dollar, which could indicate they question whether such an offer exists. There's no evidence that Pettitte has received a deadline yet from the Yankees. The well-respected longtime Yankee has made it clear that the Yankees are his first choice, as he's said he wants to pitch in the new Yankee Stadium. However, he did have one previous bitter breakup with the Yankees; that's when he went home to Houston and pitched for the Astros from 2004 through 2006. If Pettitte doesn't ever take the Yankees' longstanding offer, the Yankees will consider either making an offer to Ben Sheets or resuming discussions with Derek Lowe to round out their revamped rotation.

SI.com

Andy Pettitte, Jim McIsaac/Getty Images Andy Pettitte, Jim McIsaac/Getty Images
December 16, 2008  06:36 AM ET

It was my local Little League team.

December 16, 2008  08:14 AM ET

<With apologies to the Beatles>




Roll up, roll up for the mystery offer. Roll up, roll up for the mystery offer.
Roll up (and that's an invitation), roll up for the mystery offer.
Roll up (to make a reservation), roll up for the mystery offer.

The magical mystery offer is waiting to take you away,
Waiting to take you away.
Roll up, roll up for the mystery offer.
Roll up, roll up for the mystery offer.
Roll up (we've got everything you need), roll up for the mystery offer.
Roll up (satisfaction guaranteed), roll up for the mystery offer.
The magical mystery offer is hoping to take you away,
Hoping to take you away.

Roll up, roll up for the mystery offer.
Roll up, roll up for the mystery offer.
Roll up (and that's an invitation), roll up for the mystery offer.
Roll up (to make a reservation), roll up for the mystery offer.

The magical mystery offer is coming to take you away,
Coming to take you away.
The magical mystery offer is dying to take you away,
Dying to take you away, take you away.

December 16, 2008  08:31 AM ET

HE SHOULD TAKE THE MYSTERY OFFER BECAUSE THE YANKS DOnT GOT TIME TO WAIT FOR HIM TO TAKE THE 10 MILL SO ANDY DO ME A FAVOR TAKE IT OR TAKE IT HOW EVER YOU TAKE IT TAKE IT FAST LOL

December 16, 2008  08:58 AM ET
QUOTE(#3):

HE SHOULD TAKE THE MYSTERY OFFER BECAUSE THE YANKS DOnT GOT TIME TO WAIT FOR HIM TO TAKE THE 10 MILL SO ANDY DO ME A FAVOR TAKE IT OR TAKE IT HOW EVER YOU TAKE IT TAKE IT FAST LOL

My gut feeling tells me you feel he should take it. Is that a proper assumption?

December 16, 2008  09:10 AM ET

Take the 3 yr offer Andy. You won't be getting that from NY. You were a great Yankee but you faltered the second half of last year.

December 16, 2008  09:12 AM ET

Nice try, Andy. You better not be bluffing or you are gonna bluff yourself right into retirement.

December 16, 2008  09:16 AM ET

I'm tired of Pettitte's "I'm not appreciated" attitude. Does he forget that the Yankees stood by him through this whole HGH mess and still gave him $16 million? With people out their struggling, it's disgusting that he even has to think about a $10 million dollar offer. I think $10 million after his massive collapse at the end of 2008 is more than fair and respectful. Obviously the pinstripes don't mean that much to him, so bye bye Andy - hope your mystery team loves you because NY doesn't anymore.

December 16, 2008  09:23 AM ET

That mystery offer, if there really is one, has got to be from the Dodgers. You gotta know Joe would love to have him there, and if Lowe flies the coop, Pettite fits the bill perfectly.

December 16, 2008  09:40 AM ET

Yankees offered Pettitte a one year deal for $10 million because they know he would not take it. This way the Yankees dont look like the bad guys... Pettitte does. NOW LETS GO GET SHEETS AND WRAP THIS THING UP!!!

December 16, 2008  09:42 AM ET

I kinda think it might be from the Mets.....but the Dodgers might be dumb enough to give im 3 years (alot of $$ for them though- they are typically pretty cheap)

December 16, 2008  09:42 AM ET

I kinda think it might be from the Mets.....but the Dodgers might be dumb enough to give im 3 years (alot of $$ for them though- they are typically pretty cheap)

December 16, 2008  09:44 AM ET

I agree with Yankee27 - Sheets should have hd an offer by now to fill the last spot. I'm just wondering if the Yankees saw something on his medical reports? I'd go to war with CC, AJ, Wang, Sheets and Hughes - leave Joba in the Pen as Mo's eventual successor!

December 16, 2008  09:49 AM ET
QUOTE(#12):

I agree with Yankee27 - Sheets should have hd an offer by now to fill the last spot. I'm just wondering if the Yankees saw something on his medical reports? I'd go to war with CC, AJ, Wang, Sheets and Hughes - leave Joba in the Pen as Mo's eventual successor!

was this a serious comment???? Something on the med report????? Ray Charles could see that there is something on this guys med reports. This guys x-rays look like France circa 1917 and you wonder if they might have found something?????

You have made everyone dumber by that string of words you slapped together.

December 16, 2008  09:55 AM ET

Sounds like Scott Boras' ploy is catching on. Now everyone is trying to get teams to negotiate against a "mystery team" that has a supposed fantastic offer.

December 16, 2008  09:58 AM ET
QUOTE(#8):

That mystery offer, if there really is one, has got to be from the Dodgers. You gotta know Joe would love to have him there, and if Lowe flies the coop, Pettite fits the bill perfectly.

I agree. I could see a couple of other teams throwing an offer on the table, but this one makes the most sense. Pettitte should still have a few more years left in his arm.

December 16, 2008  10:01 AM ET

I agree with Yankee27 - Sheets should have hd an offer by now to fill the last spot. I'm just wondering if the Yankees saw something on his medical reports? I'd go to war with CC, AJ, Wang, Sheets and Hughes - leave Joba in the Pen as Mo's eventual successor
word.... this is what the yanks rotaion should be. and joba is the cloer of the future, the boy is not a starter!!!

December 16, 2008  10:03 AM ET

Got to love those mystery teams lol. Maybe it's Tom Hicks and the Rangers. They always need pitching and Andy would be close to home again.

December 16, 2008  10:05 AM ET
QUOTE(#16):

I agree with Yankee27 - Sheets should have hd an offer by now to fill the last spot. I'm just wondering if the Yankees saw something on his medical reports? I'd go to war with CC, AJ, Wang, Sheets and Hughes - leave Joba in the Pen as Mo's eventual successorword.... this is what the yanks rotaion should be. and joba is the cloer of the future, the boy is not a starter!!!

If they can get another starter I would def put Joba back in the pen. You do that and your starter only needs to go 6 innings with Joba taking 7 and 8 and Mo closing it out in the 9th.

December 16, 2008  10:10 AM ET

trinari.. where you live on the island? im from south beach, in the air force so im in bumfuck ga right now lol

 
December 16, 2008  10:12 AM ET
QUOTE(#19):

trinari.. where you live on the island? im from south beach, in the air force so im in bumfuck ga right now lol

North shore.... I think port richmond.... or port richmond center..... it's right off of forest ave.

Comment

Remember to keep your posts clean. Profanity will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Inside Manning's walk off
    Views
    130619
    Comments
    3043
  2. 2
    Teams eyeing Eagles QBs?
    Views
    19456
    Comments
    2628
  3. 3
    Yankees GM: No new deals for Big Three
    Views
    21976
    Comments
    766
  4. 4
    Kobe may miss All-Star Game
    Views
    12960
    Comments
    483
  5. 5
    Rays still have shot at Damon
    Views
    19413
    Comments
    472

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Chico 2.0
  2. 2
    BBK - Whitey
  3. 3
    rstowe
  4. 4
    gigi_iv
  5. 5
    Never NDing Struggle

Message Boards

  1. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    FSU vacates 12 football wins…
    Views
    396
    Replies
    39
  2. NFL > General NFL

    All Hail Joe Montana - The…
    Views
    309
    Replies
    43
  3. NFL > General NFL

    Shannon Sharpe didn't make the…
    Views
    77
    Replies
    4

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

SI Photos