NY Giants 56-86-90-07

NY Giants 56-86-90-07's Comments

Posted Monday April 06, 2009, About: How Giants can replace Burress
Sad that Amani Toomer is gone. He was everything that Plaxico was not ... pure class, soft-spoken, he just shut up and did his job and he did it well. From the school of Mark Bavaro. I wish Amani the best.
Posted Monday April 06, 2009, About: Report: Gunfire at Brady-Bundchen wedding
My Giants obviously missed Plax after the gunshot, but it all boils down to whether the pros of his on-the field performances outweigh the cons of his off-the-field antics (gunshot, blows off practice, fines, contract disputes, poor teammate, etc., etc.).

On the field, his biggest benefit is drawing the defenses to him, which opens up the running game as well as opening up the more average WRs.
Posted Wednesday March 25, 2009, About: Friend: Plaxico scared of prison term
Woo-wee. Congratulations ... I guess. But what exactly does that have to do with the price of tea in China?
Posted Wednesday March 25, 2009, About: Friend: Plaxico scared of prison term
Win a Super Bowl trophy, Eagles fan.

Just one.

Then maybe we'll allow you to talk to us.
Posted Wednesday March 25, 2009, About: Friend: Plaxico scared of prison term
Expand on that laundry list please. Maybe I'm missing something.

I'm not defending all that he has done, but outside of this gun incident I don't see anything that would have a typical, non-famous person facing jail time!

Fender benders, domestic verbal arguments, an unlicensed gun in his cabinet, do these all really qualify as automatic jail time?

Previous poster said it best. Plax is not a career criminal, he is a career moron.
Posted Wednesday March 25, 2009, About: Friend: Plaxico scared of prison term
Exactly.
Posted Wednesday March 25, 2009, About: Friend: Plaxico scared of prison term
Agree. Jury is still out. Right now I consider him "good", not "great".

But as Giants fans we shouldn't compare him to other QBs in the league. We should start by comparing him to what our own franchise has had in that position ... Kent Graham, Dave Brown, Joe Pisarcick, etc., etc., etc.

Makes Eli a bit more qualified for the position don't you think?
Posted Wednesday March 25, 2009, About: Friend: Plaxico scared of prison term
Equally important to Plaxico's WR abilities is the fact that he draws the defenses to himself, leaving the other "more average" WRs wide open. That is the true value of Plax to this team.

Please, no more shot guns, unless they are formations.
Posted Wednesday March 25, 2009, About: Friend: Plaxico scared of prison term
Maybe this scare will finally get Plax to act his age.

Although it could have been worse, the gun incident hurt nobody but himself (well, and the Giants run at a repeat title). Most of you will disagree but I honestly think he should get probation, not jail. Unknown names in similar circumstances would get the same.

Then, if he does it yet again, well, Plax, you're on your own.
Posted Monday March 23, 2009, About: Giants GM: We'll take Plaxico back
No way. Not even close.
Posted Monday December 08, 2008, About: Eagles go right at distracted Pierce
The Giants have proven they are a mentally-tough team, so Pierce's poor performance had nothing to do with Plaxico in my mind. Give the Eagles some credit, and point the majority of the blame to play-calling, to Eli and to some key dropped passes. We got this loss out of our way, eliminating the "peaking too soon" argument. Positioning ourselves very nicely for the playoffs ...
Posted Tuesday December 02, 2008, About: Plaxico's trouble could benefit this Giant
Toomer is humble, quiet, soft-spoken, hard-working and he gets the job done. In other words, he is everything that Plaxico is not.
Posted Monday November 24, 2008, About: Eagles looking to Kolb in 2009
Philadelphia's "classy" fans deserve exactly what they're getting ... an empty Super Bowl trophy case.
Posted Monday November 17, 2008, About: Brees shows Shockey who's boss
Over-rated, self-centered arse. Good for the G-Men for dumping him. We won a Super Bowl without the guy and probably wouldn't have had he not been injured.
Posted Tuesday November 04, 2008, About: Giants may cut Super Bowl hero
Jersey-born-and-bred too. But ... outside of the now infamous Super Bowl catch, he did very little in 2007. You can't judge a player on one play, no matter how great the significance of that one play was. Wish him the best if he is cut. If not, maybe Moss should go.
Posted Tuesday October 28, 2008, About: Brett Favre's wife angry at media
Welcome to New York Mrs. Favre. You're not in Wisconsin any more.
Posted Tuesday October 21, 2008, About: Can Eli fix Plaxico-Coughlin feud?
Hey Plax, the Giants have always taken pride in being a classy organization. You are not acting with class. The last time that happened with a player we shipped him off to New Orleans for some quality draft picks. Follow Amani Toomer's lead, probably the classiest guy on the team.
Posted Tuesday October 21, 2008, About: Eagles exec takes shots at Cowboys
Eagles ownership is obviously as ignorant as their fans. What an idiot.
Posted Monday October 13, 2008, About: Giants interested in Gonzalez
Why try to fix something that is not broken? The Giants are 4-0, are marching on all cylinders and have a very qualified TE in Kevin Boss. Don't mess with our great chemistry Mara!

The Si.com Cover Hub Go to the Cover Hub

Stub Hub

The 2009 schedule has been released. Search for tickets!

Truth & Rumors

MOST POPULAR

  1. 1
    Cowher to Bears or Texans?
    Views
    68566
    Comments
    3103
  2. 2
    Yankees to cut down on spending
    Views
    9149
    Comments
    1160
  3. 3
    Disrespected Ryan takes dig at Moss
    Views
    10970
    Comments
    712
  4. 4
    Ochocinco condoms in stores soon?
    Views
    1294
    Comments
    559
  5. 5
    Red Sox-Jays deal-killer?
    Views
    7368
    Comments
    472

Most Active Users

Comments + Blog Posts + Throwdowns

  1. 1
    Chico 2.0
  2. 2
    BBK - Now it's all football
  3. 3
    rstowe
  4. 4
    gigi_iv
  5. 5
    Never NDing Struggle

Message Boards

  1. NCAAF > General NCAAF

    Longhorns vs. Aggies…
    Views
    334
    Replies
    63

  2. MMA > General MMA

    The Politics Thread
    Views
    138
    Replies
    39

  3. NFL > General NFL

    New England-New Orleans
    Views
    138
    Replies
    28

Blogs

SI.com

Swimsuit

Ashley AllenAshley Allen
Cheney LarschiedCheney Larschied

SI Photos

Back in Time: November 24Back in Time: November 24
Cheerleader of the WeekCheerleader of the Week

SI Writers

Top Stories

SI Vault

11.05.90 Issue View This Issue Read All Articles
06.17.68 Issue View This Issue Read All Articles